Table of contents

When your business faces overdue debts, hiring a collection agency can be a practical solution to recover what’s owed. However, selecting the right agency requires careful consideration. A poorly chosen agency could not only fail to recover your debts but also damage your company’s reputation. To ensure you make an informed decision, here are the key factors to consider when hiring a debt collection agency.

1. Experience and Reputation Matter

Look for Industry-Specific Expertise

Not all debt collection agencies are equipped to handle debts in every industry. Each sector comes with its own challenges, and understanding these nuances is crucial for successful debt recovery. For example:

  • Healthcare debt collection: Healthcare providers must be careful to comply with HIPAA regulations while collecting debts.
  • Retail debt collection: In retail, a collection agency must be skilled in dealing with high volumes of smaller accounts while maintaining brand reputation.
  • Financial services: Agencies that work with financial services must have experience in more complex collections, including loans and mortgages.

According to the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB), industry-specific knowledge is key to ensuring compliance with federal and state regulations. An agency that understands your industry will be more effective in recovering debts.

Look for a collection agency that has experience in your sector to ensure they follow the right approach and have the necessary expertise.

At Shepherd Outsourcing, we’ve helped businesses in healthcare, retail, financial services, and more, tailoring our services to the specific needs of each industry.

Check References and Testimonials

Always ask for references and read client testimonials before committing to an agency. A reputable agency should be happy to provide you with references from businesses similar to yours. A quick conversation with past clients can provide valuable insight into how the agency operates and whether they deliver results.

According to a 2020 study by TransUnion, companies that carefully vetted debt collection agencies reported a 35% higher recovery rate compared to those that didn't perform adequate due diligence. This proves that checking references and reputation can lead to more successful outcomes.

2. Compliance and Licensing

Verify Licensing and Bonding

Debt collection agencies are required by law to be licensed and bonded in each state they operate. In the U.S., each state has its own licensing requirements, which ensures the agency is operating legally and within regulatory guidelines.

A study by the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) found that nearly 25% of consumers reported some form of violation by a debt collector. Hiring an agency that is properly licensed and bonded can protect your business from potential legal issues, fines, and penalties.

When considering an agency, ask for proof of their licensing and bonding to avoid working with one that may expose you to unnecessary risks.

Ensure Compliance with FDCPA

The Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA) sets clear rules for how debt collectors can interact with consumers. Agencies that comply with the FDCPA avoid practices that could damage their reputation or open the door to legal challenges.

The CFPB reported that complaints about debt collectors in 2022 accounted for over 20% of all consumer complaints received. This highlights the importance of working with an agency that operates within the bounds of the law to avoid consumer complaints and legal actions.

3. Collection Methods and Professionalism

Avoid Damaging Your Reputation

The methods a collection agency uses directly affect how your business is perceived. Aggressive tactics, threats, or harassment can not only fail to recover debts but also damage your company’s reputation. The CFPB also reported that 70% of consumers found debt collection tactics "abusive," including frequent phone calls and aggressive messaging.

Make sure the collection agency you hire follows best practices in terms of professionalism and tact. They should be firm but respectful, preserving your relationship with the debtor and maintaining your brand’s image.

At Shepherd Outsourcing, we emphasize the importance of professionalism, ensuring that every interaction with a debtor is courteous and respectful, protecting your brand’s reputation.

Focus on Clear Communication and Professionalism

Clear, consistent communication is essential for successful debt recovery. A professional debt collection agency should keep you informed about the status of each account, communicate effectively with debtors, and follow up regularly.

A study by ACA International found that businesses that communicated effectively with debtors had a 30% higher recovery rate compared to those that didn’t prioritize communication.

When reviewing agencies, ask how they communicate with clients and ensure they offer transparent reporting systems.

4. Technological Capabilities and Tools

Use of Advanced Tools like Skip Tracing

Skip tracing is the process of locating a debtor who has moved or changed contact information. This technique can significantly increase the chances of successful debt recovery. According to FICO, 80% of all delinquent accounts require some form of skip tracing.

A collection agency that uses advanced tools for skip tracing can locate debtors more efficiently and recover debts faster. Agencies that invest in technology like predictive dialing systems, artificial intelligence, and data analytics can improve the chances of a successful collection.

At Shepherd Outsourcing, we use the latest tools in skip tracing and data analytics to ensure your debts are recovered swiftly and efficiently.

Online Account Management Portal

In today’s digital world, managing accounts online is crucial for businesses. An online portal allows you to track progress, access reports, and stay informed in real-time about the recovery efforts. According to a survey by NACM (National Association of Credit Management), 78% of businesses said they preferred agencies that offered online account access for better visibility into the collection process.

When evaluating agencies, ensure they provide online access to make monitoring the debt recovery process easier for you.

5. Insurance and Legal Safeguards

Ensure Errors and Omissions Insurance

Errors and omissions (E&O) insurance is an essential protection for both you and the collection agency. This insurance protects you in case the agency makes an error that results in financial loss or legal issues.

AIG reports that nearly 30% of businesses that deal with debt collection face legal claims or lawsuits. Having an agency that carries E&O insurance gives your business a safety net if any mistakes are made during the collection process.

Legal Protection Against Lawsuits

In addition to E&O insurance, ensure the agency has proper legal safeguards in place to protect both parties in case of disputes. A collection agency that follows all laws and regulations will reduce the chances of costly lawsuits or penalties.

6. Fee Structure

Contingency vs. Flat Fees

Debt collection agencies typically operate on one of two fee structures: contingency-based or flat fees.

  • Contingency fees: The agency takes a percentage of what they successfully collect. This model is often preferred because it aligns the interests of the agency with yours — they only get paid if they recover the debt.
  • Flat fees: You pay a fixed amount for the service, regardless of the outcome. While predictable, this model may not be as effective if the agency doesn’t have a strong success rate.

According to ACA International, agencies working on a contingency basis typically recover 20-30% more in debt compared to agencies with flat fee arrangements.

It’s important to consider not just the percentage charged but also the agency’s recovery success rate. A lower fee with poor recovery rates may ultimately cost you more.

Evaluate the Agency’s Success Rate

Fees should be just one part of the equation. A lower fee percentage from an agency with poor success rates may end up being more costly than working with an agency that charges a higher fee but delivers better results.

7. Contracts and Terms of Service

Review Contract Terms Carefully

Before signing any contract, ensure that the terms are clear and favorable. Pay close attention to:

  • The duration of the agreement
  • The agency’s cancellation policy
  • The termination clauses
  • Any hidden fees

Clear, fair terms protect both you and the agency and help avoid misunderstandings.

Negotiate Fair Terms

A reputable agency will be willing to negotiate terms to suit your business needs. Don’t hesitate to discuss payment schedules, success fees, and reporting methods. Shepherd Outsourcing works closely with clients to ensure all terms are mutually agreed upon, with no surprises.

Conclusion

Choosing the right debt collection agency is crucial to ensuring you recover the funds owed to your business without harming your brand’s reputation or exposing yourself to legal risk. By considering factors such as industry experience, compliance with regulations, collection methods, technology, fees, and contract terms, you can make an informed decision.

Shepherd Outsourcing combines experience, cutting-edge technology, and a commitment to professionalism to help businesses recover their debts quickly and ethically. With a strong track record across industries, they offer transparent pricing and flexible contracts, making them an excellent choice for your debt recovery needs.

Taking the time to evaluate collection agencies carefully can help you protect your bottom line while ensuring a smooth debt recovery process.